| Recording acoustic
guitar is a
challenge, to be sure. The
sound hole can really put out some
lows that can be uneven when compared to a live in-person experience.
the mic back is
fine, although at 3 feet you're getting room
sound as well, and a less immediate version of the guitar. If the room
acoustics are good, that's ok. Try a foot instead, aimed between the
soundhole and the end of the guitar where the neck is joined. If you
want more lows, just twist the mic more toward the sound hole (or don't
twist it and just add some eq).
stereo I've often used
the X-Y technique, with two 451's or C501E's
about a foot back - crossed in an X shape (the barrels of the mics at
90 degrees crossed at the center) - one pointing toward the mid-neck,
the other pointed midway between the sound hole and the end of the
guitar. That avoids the direct lows projected by the sound hole, gets
the warmth of the large portion of the body of the guitar and the
clarity of the neck/string area. You can vary the distance from the
guitar and vary the position of the point where the mics X intersect.
Try the capsules closer together, farther apart, just experiment. I've
also used C12's with the capsules roughly in the same position.
method you can try
is one of the very earliest stereo methods
called the Mid-Side Encoded technique. For guitar, have two mics
positioned so the capsules are one above the other. Mic 1 should be set
on cardioid aimed at the guitar. Mic 2 should be in a figure-8 aimed
with the front of the mic pointed 90 degrees off Mic 1... basically
looking left-right from the guitar.
encoding can happen as
you track to tape, or at mixdown time. To
track the encoding to the multitrack, take your center cardioid mic on
one fader assigned to the center of two busses, say 9 and 10. Next,
take the figure-8 mic to a mult (a patchbay's version of a y-chord) and
bring it's signal up on two faders, one bussed to 9, one to 10. Put the
fader assigned to buss 10 out of phase. You can now control the stereo
image by varying the level of the figure-8 faders. Remember to monitor
the signal coming back from your multitrack - don't send these faders
to your mix buss. The advantage to tracking your image to tape is that
it saves a channel fader at mixdown time, but you are stuck with how
wide the image can go at that point.
other way to handle the
encoding is to just record each mic to a
separate channel on the multitrack. Then in mixdown, do what I
described above. This gives you the flexibility of modifying the image
as much or as little as you like within the context of your mix. It
just takes up one more fader. If you don't have a mult in your patch
bay, just pan the figure-8 to the left, assign it to an unused buss (or
aux send), bring the output of that buss (or aux) into another fader
out-of-phase panned right.
using stereo miking,
always check your sound in mono (usually a
button on the console monitor section) to make sure that the sound is
still good. If the mics have a phase problem, the mono sound will
either sound way to soft or have some mid-rangey tone that is too
different from the stereo sound. Move the mics till you have good
sounds in both stereo and mono. Same thing with acoustic piano!
have been known to
compress acoustic guitar often, but it really
depends on the instrument, the player, the placement of the mics, the
kind of music that's being recorded, etc. If you're using Pro Tools or
such, try to get the sound the way you want it from the get-go so that
you do the minimum amount of processing in the computer. The
recalculations in computer processors tampers with the coherency of the
original sound, and dimensional qualities can suffer if a lot of
number-crunching is going on there.
Q) My dad was talking about phase
cancellation if I [used multiple mics]. Any idea on how phase
cancellation might come into play with that technique? -Joe
definitely plays a part. Use that mono button on
your console to find out what's happening and what's not happening.
Often when I would use back mics in conjunction with front mics, the
resulting phase cancellation sounded very cool! It can be used to make
a lot of variations in the sound, kinda like Queen did many years ago.
if you have an out-of-phase and in-phase mic panned hard left
and hard right, there can be a significantly wide sound, but it will be
lacking in solidity in the bottom end and mid-bottom. That results in
something that can sound artificial, not muscluar. Radio station phase
correllation and issues with vinyl don't make that type of stereo
spread completely desireable.
Much is "forgiveable" in digital listening, but "old school" ideas are
a good balance to keep in mind - like mono compatability. After all if
you hear your music in an elevator when you turn 50, you'll appreciate
the sound in that 5" speaker overhead! (Yikes that's a left-field
reason to keep an eye on phase!) More important for now, if your
uber-wide-phased tracks go to a TV show (yes some folks still don't
have stereo television), the cancellation could
cause your guitars to partially disappear or sound small.
6/10/00 Modified 3/22/03
Check your polarity
Secrets of Miking Drums and Amps
Get ready for MASTER
QUALITY High Resolution Audio sold online!
|George Duke - Grammy Nominated
Akwid - Grammy Nominated
|Sympathy for the Record Industry